Seared Sea Scallop with Fennel (recipe by Jamie from Top Chef)

As I mentioned before, Eric and I watched quite a bit of Top Chef while house sitting for his parents. One of the contestants, Jamie, cooked a scallop poorly in a challenge. So in the next challenge she decided to go with scallops again to prove she could cook them well. Many people criticized this decision, both on and off the show. In fact Eric decided Fabio was hilarious as he spouted “The show’s called Top Chef! Not Top Scallop!” But the judges loved her dish and seemed to appreciate her decision. I’d been wanting to try fennel and decided this would be a great dish to test.

I had to change a few things about her recipe (if it’s in fact her recipe, I don’t know who compiles the recipes from the show, which are filled with typos and misinformation!). For instance it says to cool the chopped fennel in the oven rather than cook it. Hmmm. I had to scale it down to serve 2 instead of 7, I also didn’t include the olives because Eric calls olives poison and hates them. Because I made a smaller amount of the fennel puree, I didn’t strain it to make it smooth, but I like chunky textures better anyway.

Eric really liked the dish and was pretty impressed with it. I liked it too although it was like nothing I’ve ever tasted. The flavor combination was so new I had to have several bites to decide if I liked it. The licorice flavor of the salad was a little strong for me, I think I’d like a little more fronds and orange and a little less shaved fennel bulb. It was fun making a recipe from the show and I may experiment with some more. I kept the rest of the meal very simple with a parmesan pasta and steamed broccoli with cabernet vinegar.

Seared Sea Scallops with a Roasted Fennel and Garlic Cream, and Salad of Shaved Fennel, Mint, Oranges, and Fennel Fronds.


1/3 head fennel, chopped
1 TBS olive oil
2 cloves garlic, roasted
1 Tbs Crème fraîche
salt to taste

1/3 head fennel, shaved thin using a vegetable peeler
1 tsp dried mint
1/2 orange, peeled and chopped
1 TBS fresh squeezed Orange Juice
1 TBS lemon oil
salt to taste
1 TBS chopped fennel fronds

2 mid sized scallops


Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Place the fennel into an oven safe dish and drizzle with olive oil and salt. Cover with foil and cook until soft, about 1/2 hour. Place the fennel into food processor and puree until smooth. Add the garlic and crème fraîche and puree again. Add salt and pepper, if necessary. Reserve warm.

Combine Fennel, mint and orange about 10 minutes before serving. Season with orange juice and lemon oil. Adjust seasoning with salt.

Season scallops with sea salt and pepper then sear on each side. Place the warm fennel puree in the center of the plate. Top with scallop. Top scallop with fennel salad. Drizzle with a little lemon oil and serve.

Posts may contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product through an affiliate link, your costs will be the same but Eating Richly Even When You're Broke will receive a small commission. This helps us to cover some of the costs for this site. Thank you so much for your support!

No Responses to “Seared Sea Scallop with Fennel (recipe by Jamie from Top Chef)”

  1. Suzanna
    March 15, 2009 at 11:34 pm #

    I saw that episode of Top Chef, and I was a tad skeptical about the judges’ rave reviews about her dish. But, after your nice review and seeing your beautiful plating, I might just have to test this one out! And you’re right, all of the recipes posted on the Bravo website have way too many grammatical errors… and they never scale down the recipes for those of us who don’t have to cook for 10 million people. The recipe for Carla’s oyster stew/chowder called for ingredients for 100 people!

  2. julie jams
    March 17, 2009 at 10:01 am #

    Such a great post! I just love scallops so good job.

  3. Diana
    March 17, 2009 at 11:38 am #

    Isn’t is ridiculous Suzanna? I seriously wonder who puts the recipes on the site.

    Thanks Julie!

  4. lisaiscooking
    March 22, 2009 at 9:05 am #

    Looks delicious! The fennel puree sounds great with scallops.

  5. Ginny
    April 3, 2009 at 6:44 pm #

    That photo is excellent! I want to dive right in! :)

  6. Rumela
    June 7, 2009 at 8:53 pm #

    Thanks for the Fennel puree recipe. Last summer I ate them at a party and has been looking for an authentic recipe ever since. Now I will be able to make them myself. Thanks again for shearing your post.

Leave a Reply